Skip to main content

“What is best in music is not to be found in the notes.”

Gustav Mahler— Gustav Mahler · 1860 – 1911

Source: *Gustav Mahler*, Passage concerning Mahler's conducting and the relation between the score and musical expression, 1958 · Check the source

Verified attributionWhat we know
What remains uncertain
Translation: translated by Adagely.

Understanding the quote

Bruno Walter recalls that Mahler felt the score was only the starting point for music-making. In his account, the best in music is not set down in the notes. Walter ties this remainder beyond the written score to Mahler's conducting, described as passionate and like a personal confession.

The story behind it

Walter's book was originally published in 1958, with the cited English edition appearing in 1966.

Three challenges to live it

In the app, you pick the one that fits your day, and in the evening you say how it went.

  1. Pick a well-known song and sing or hum it with personal feeling: change the tempo, the softness, the intensity, until it sounds like you.

    The score is only a starting point: by adding your passion and personal confession to a melody, you look for what is best in music beyond the notes.

  2. Listen to one piece of music with your eyes closed, from start to finish, doing nothing else. Notice what you feel beyond the notes.

    If the best in music is not in the notes, close listening lets you sense that remainder: the passion and personal confession that go beyond the score.

  3. Ask someone which piece of music moves them most and why, then listen for what it makes them feel rather than for technical description.

    What is best in music is not set down in the notes: by listening to what a piece makes someone feel, you touch that personal, passionate part beyond the score.

What do you love that cannot be written down or captured in notes?

Report an error

Does an attribution, a source or a translation look wrong? Tell us: every report is read, and the entry is corrected if needed.

Your message reaches us by e-mail; your address is only used to reply to you. Privacy.

Themes

All quotes by Gustav Mahler →