Skip to main content

“The symphony must be like the world. It must embrace everything.”

Gustav Mahler— Gustav Mahler · 1860 – 1911

Source: no specific work is documented · Check the source

Disputed attributionWhat we know
What is documented
The quotation is attributed to Gustav Mahler, not Jean Sibelius: it occurs in an account of Mahler's contrasting view of the symphony's nature.
What remains uncertain
These words are spoken by Gustav Mahler, replying to Jean Sibelius. Translation: translated by Adagely.

Understanding the quote

The words occur in an account of a conversation in which Jean Sibelius admires the symphony's severity of style and the profound logic creating an inner connection between all its motifs. Mahler answers with his contrasting view of the symphony's nature. For him, a symphony must be like the world and embrace everything.

The story behind it

Daniel Gregory Mason's The Art of Music, the Gutenberg book where the phrase was first sought, mentions Mahler's ten symphonies only in passing and does not contain the quote.

Three challenges to live it

In the app, you pick the one that fits your day, and in the evening you say how it went.

  1. Observe your surroundings for five minutes and note ten very different things: a sound, a smell, a color, an object, a person, a light.

    Mahler wanted the symphony to be like the world and embrace everything. Noting ten varied things means taking everything in with your eyes, leaving nothing out.

  2. Make a short collage, drawing or playlist of seven items with nothing in common, joyful and dark alike, and give it a title.

    Mahler saw the symphony as like the world, embracing everything. A creation that welcomes the joyful and the dark alike tries to embrace everything.

  3. Ask someone whose view of the world differs from yours to explain how they see it, then listen all the way through without interrupting.

    In the account, Mahler answers Sibelius with a contrasting view, one that wants to embrace everything. Listening to a different view makes room for more of the world.

What in your life deserves to be embraced rather than ordered or pared down?

Report an error

Does an attribution, a source or a translation look wrong? Tell us: every report is read, and the entry is corrected if needed.

Your message reaches us by e-mail; your address is only used to reply to you. Privacy.

Themes

All quotes by Gustav Mahler →